Years ago, before Facebook, Tweeting and the evolved social networking of the internets I used to do an American Idol re-cap via email with some friends. It was pretty freaking hilarious. I know what you’re thinking, gosh I thought Rhi was way less “middle America” than this. Nope, I’m totally lame, sometimes I even shop at Market Basket before I watch.
Anyway, so last night, I invited an American Idol newbie to watch with me. Here some of our commentary…
Speaking of Market Basket, is it just me or did all this music remind you of something that would be playing in one? Or as Newbie put it, “all these songs remind me of the music you’d hear in the lobby of a Crowne Plaza Hotel after just waking up in a stranger’s bed with a raging hangover.”
Naima – Trainwreck performance. Girl’s going home. She’s got some urban Ani DiFranco thing going on where she wears every brightly colored accessory in her closet. Giant earrings. Newbie on Naima, “Do you think her earrings are bigger than her brain.”
Paul McDonald – I don’t get the whole voice thing, I’m not into it. Plus, the kid dresses like Chris Martin lite (Coldplay) He kind of reminds me of what would’ve happened to Chris Martin if he never made it and was just some dude that drank all day and then bothered people with his “demo tape” outside of subway stations.
Thia Megia – Someone once told me never to trust someone with two first names (Justin Bobby) but I’m going to expand that warning to people with names that rhyme. Or to people whose parents wear matching leather jackets. I almost fell off my couch when the girl started singing Pocahontas for the “year she was born song.” Yeah, 1995.
James Durbin - Is that a scarf hanging out of his back pocket? Ughhhhh – you’re not making it to the finale sweetie. Leather studded bandana shoe covers? Really?
Haley Reinhart - sang Whitney Houston but it reminded me of Anita Baker. My mom used to listen to that tape like someone was going to steal it out of our Oldsmobile Cutlass Ciera if we didn’t listen to sides A and B twice a day. I think this girl is a contender but man, weak song choice.
Stefano Langone - The kid that closes his eyes, the kid that looks like a Jersey Shore cast member, the kid that’s actually decent.
Pia – the girl that seemed like she could sing anything and look hot in anything. Looked pretty brutal in her pantsuit.
Scottie - this kid dressed up as Elvis his entire life.
Seth Rogan – Kid sang Smells like Teen Spirit. First time Nirvana has ever been on Idol. Courtney Love must need some $. I like anyone that takes a risk and tries to appeal to the Gen X-ers. I’m rooting for him. Wait; is this the same kid writing Bethenny’s food blog?
Lauren - Dear Lord. I think Lauren’s parents are like 27. And is her mom wearing a plaid scally cap and a matching fuchsia t-shirt? This girl can wail, but Melissa Etheridge, really? What songbook were the Idols allowed to choose from, a dive bar jukebox in Montana?
Comments below please. And yes, I know I missed a few contenders. They bored me.